Where the mind is free........

Thursday, June 3, 2010

Advise on divorce from the colonel


Separations and such

It is amazing the kind of responses people come up with when they know of the separation. But the most pragmatic and enlightening of them was from a Colonel in the Indian Army who happens to be in my neighbourhood. He said 'just think one part of your life is over and another has started'.

True to myself I did not capture the meaning right then until I got it in the sense of burning bridges. Because that is what the marching army does when it is necessary and inevitable. Then it is either do or die rather than retreat and be with the past and worst still to whine.

But more importantly my take on this thing called separation and divorce is that why not consider it as a new form of family? Where the parenthood and responsibilities are in tact and not neglected, but for some reasons the man woman relation is not there.Because of personal differences one is not able to live with the other, but of course one does not shirk the responsibilities of parenthood. One might argue that the responsibility of parenthood is to keep the family in one piece. Well that has not taken place and keeping it together brings in bickerings and then the worst for the offsprings.

Instead why not time share on upbringing of the children? That way the child does not feel deprived. The parents don't feel tied up. And the children have the best of both worlds. The only thing left is the circumstances of the break up. Well then burn it. That is immaterial.

What is true is that the upbringing of the parents themselves have been too different that they are comfortable on their own......... Hail family, not so hail marriage.....

People who influenced me: Alexandr Solzhenitsyn


The man who saw it all and then came to warn all...


Russia hold a fascination for any one from Kerala at least those from my generation and before. Russia or the Soviet Union was a formidable power, in fact the only formidable power to balance the US. Russia came into our homes through a publication called the Soviet Union in the seventies as I remember. It was published on rather good paper but slightly lesser in quality than SPAN, the American counterpart.


Even people who had no reading habit like my uncle subscribed to it because it was cheap or even free and probably a part of the soviet propaganda. Besides it was known that India though non-aligned had a bent towards USSR with the Nehruvian Socialism still lurking around.


So the pictures of USSR were vivid in my mind and in those days 70s and early 80s I used to tune in for programmes in Malayalam on the Short wave and voila there was Moscow Radio with about 15 minutes in Malayalam apart from other broadcasters like FEBA radio which was mainly on religious themes. Another one of the Malayalam programmes was by the Sri Lanka Broadcasting Corporation with mostly entertainment from film songs and Vatican Radio mostly on Catholic news.


Here I was sitting in one corner of Kerala listening to pure propaganda of the Soviet era. Whatever news we used to receive from Malayalam and English newspapers back home had a fine twist when heard from Moscow Radio. Thus what was happening in Diego Garcia an island nation was actually American Imperialism in full swing. What was happening in Afghanistan then occupied by the USSR was purely uplifting and so on.


I have often wondered about living in a country where there was a dictatorship of some kind and having to hear one sided news. Will I know it is one sided ? Or will they clothe it so cleverly as to illusion the listener that he was listening to unbiased news? What if the populace was immersed in semi truths and lies? Will they ever know? Will the fish know the water until it is taken out ?


Amidst such unchildlike thoughts I grew until some time later I read about Alexandr Solzhenitsyn mostly from TIME magazine. The cuddliness of MISHA the mascot of MOscow Olympics, the cute pictures of happy people and scientists that we saw in SOVIET UNION, the magazine were all gone. Stalin's excesses were known from C. P. Snow though as a personal quirk.


Here was a man from the dead exile in Siberia. Much like Benhur coming back from the galleys to tell the story. In one go the totalitarian tendencies of the dictatorship had a sudden exposure and appearance in this bearded frail man who survived only because he had an inner spark that no gulag could bend or break.


But what is this man's greatness. Though he suffered the extreme he liked his country. He was in a way the country in essense with the accumulation of all the harsh winter and hardships meted out by fellow men. Who else could condemn the materialsim of the west in the same breath after suffering the brutality of the East ?


From wikipedia I gathered more. Here indeed is a man who had been to Siberia for "libelous speech" about the leaders, and yet his publication had been officially permitted. He warned about the dangers of Communist aggression and the weakening of the moral fiber of the West. He harshly criticised what he saw as the ugliness and spiritual vapidity of the dominant pop culture of the modern West, including television and much of popular music. He praised the political liberty which was one of the enduring strengths of western democratic societies. He implored the West not to "lose sight of its own values, its historically unique stability of civic life under the rule of law—a hard-won stability which grants independence and space to every private citizen.


Who better than him who has suffered all and survived to tell!


While faulting Soviet society for denying fair legal treatment of people, he also faulted the West for being too legalistic: "A society which is based on the letter of the law and never reaches any higher, is taking very scarce advantage of the high level of human possibilities."



And then comes the triumph. The human soul longs for things higher, warmer, and purer than those offered by today's mass living habits ... by TV stupor and by intolerable music. Solzhenitsyn gradually turned into a philosophically-minded Christian as a result of his experience in prison and the camps. Suffering indeed is uplifting in his case.

He remembered all those who preceded him. Men who saw a time when moral fiber was stronger than the material harshness and when material progress did come, saw sadly, that men forgot the fibre.


And cried thus:-

"Men have forgotten God; that's why all this has happened."
"Men have forgotten God; that's why all this has happened."

Here is to me the greatness of this man raised and encouraged by a widowed mother. That amidst the gloom he survived and came back, his moral fibre in tact to criticise both mundane blocs in the same breath and enlighten humanity in the process....

People who influenced me: J. Krishnamurty


The man who would not have any followers.....


Another of those rather unlikely figures for this blog, Jiddu came to my radar when he left this planet in 1986. I was in LOYOLA Madras at that time and the newspapers espcially HINDU carried reviews and euologies on Jiddu.





He was born a Hindu, but there was very little of that in him. Instead one cannot find his religion when one reads him. No mention of religion except may be as a description of a situation in his writings. He was a religion by himself. His main emphasis was awareness. Pure awareness.. Almost on the border of inaction but his thoughts do have the power of action in themselves. He gives clarity to such an extent that by the end of the reading one is trasnported to another world.





I do have the books 'Commentaries on Living' and 'Meating Life' in my collection gifted to me by one Mr. Narayanan a colleague of my former spouse.





He was perhaps the first that I came across as the inventor of the idea that the very idea of observing changes the observed, the very act of observation produces a change in the object, that real objective observation is impossible. Today this is being touted by the western philosophies as well perhaps proved in more empirical ways.





In its place the awareness of oneself and one's thoughts is what counts to him. There is a parallel in Jung where the objective of Psychology is greater consciousness, of bringing that in the unconscious to the conscious. Modern emotional intelligence would say be aware of what is bringing about a particular feeling and act upon that as in rational emotive therapy.





He also says that the world is what it is also because of you however small you are and therefore one cannot complain about the world. His ultimate greatness comes from his insistence that he does not need any followers because that would be contrary to his teachings. The very idea of followers would mean institutions and institutions would be hindrances to real knowing and awareness because instituiotns will develop instituitionalised vested interests!!!!!!





The ultimate of individualism and the complete absense of politics and religion, the pinnacle of pure existence.. that was Jiddu Krishnamurty as I understand him....

Wednesday, June 2, 2010

What it means to be a father?


Fathers and generations


My great grandfather on the paternal side died in 1816. His eldest son was ordained as a CMI priest on 15/08/1916 on the day after. The ordination was said to be in Mangalore. The son true to his ascetic type did not want to postpone his ordination. Instead he dedicated his first mass to his father dead and cold back home. Great grandfather had a limp in one leg which one I do not know. What little I know of him comes from an uncle of mine who died in 2005 at the age of 99+ who had only to talk about great grandfather after 15 minutes of peasantries otherwise. Great grand father died apprently of dtowning in a pond very close to the Vazhakkulam town although the reasons are not known.


I know for sure that the land that belongs to our family that in my estimate together is around 40 acres in Vazhakkulam with my dad's cousins was all the great garandfather's hard work. Besides there were more near the CMI church in Vazhakkulam and some in Avoly which were disposed by my earlier generations.


I have commented elsewhere that my grandfather did not make much only sold some that his father, my great grand father gave him.I do attribute it to the fact that great grandfather lived before the world wars but grandfather lived before during and after the world wars. This reason is my own conjecture and has no validation except my own thesis.


So did my great great grandfather on the maternal side who built six houses one each for his six sons.


What does a father do?


I mean biologically the greater role is that of the mother. The father has to trust the mother's faithfulness even to father. And then he toils to bring up a family. In this process he may develop some rudeness, rough edges, callus and it is said by earlier generations that the presence of the father was that of the tiger in quality. The father usually thinks that he can enjoy after he has provided for his wife and children in general for the family in an impersonal way. But just as he thinks he has provided, the next deficiency comes in, in some form or the other and then he postpones the enjoyment. His enjoyment, rather the imagined enjoyment is a happy contented wife and kids bubbling with mirth although he smiles only internally. He even holds his expressed happiness in abeyance in an inner commitment as the provider.


The mother's enjoyment is more direct and spontaneous and immediate. There is the contentment about the breast feeding that reportedly is indescribable. The mirth and the joy are very much like the tigress and the cubs in frolic.But the father's joy? Even the sorrows of the mother may be expressed and spontaneous. But the father's sorrow? He has the burden of the family even if it is broken by the neighbour or even the mother.


My great grandfather may not have had any idea of owning or enjoying what he made. His instincts were only about a family down the generations which he has had no idea of seeing or even imagining except in abstraction. Siring the child or children is part of the story but the real story is that of the unexpressed fears and anxieties of the father no story ever fully captures. And that too not just for the children or grandchildren but down the years into generations.


It may well be for the women to gossip and jealosies and the worries of wrinkles but the grace of the man is the real one that perpetuates this race. To have great grand children who remembers great grand fathers is great although in one's life time there can never be a surety that one day one of them will remember. Yet the present day father also instinctively toils and toils and bears one day at a time again and again.....

CII best practices experience sharing lecture


In october 2005 I was invited for a lecture on the best practices, recreating the HR function. The audience was of practitioners form the city and outskirts. Since mine was academic oriented the lecture left too few questions at the end of it.......




Text of the lecture delivered at the CII HR Excellence and Experience sharing convention on the topic
Best Practices: Recreating the HR function delivered on 14th October, 2005 at Hotel Renaissance Kochi.


Shelly Jose

Introduction


At the outset it may be well worth remembering and reminding oneself about the Change from process oriented HRM to transformation oriented strategic HRM which everyone of us HR professionals is aware of.


Jeffrey Mello defines Strategic HRM as involving the development of a consistent aligned collection of practices programmes and policies to facilitate the achievement of the organisation’s strategic objectives. The changes that we mentioned earlier have the following implications. In general HR has moved from predictability oriented bureaucratic control to organic free flowing control, from specialisation to broader job design, from independent to interdependent tasks, from command and control to more autonomous modes, from people as costs to people as investments and from reactive to proactive approach.


The responses from the actual world of organizations to this shift have generally taken the following forms. At the basic is the universalistic approach where the practices are enumerated and fits all irrespective of the other factors . Secondly , Contingency approach where the approaches depend on the situations and thirdly the configurational approach where the grand gestalt of practices do have unique implications and results. The first approach namely the universalistic are the ones also called the best practices approach by Delery and Doty. Best practices approach is therefore a set of practices that can be used irrespective of other variables such as the organization, Industry or the larger context and is therefore generically prescriptive.
Contingency approach posits that the HR practices must be consistent with the other aspects of the organization and demands ‘Fit’ or ‘congruence’. This is the most prevalent interpretation of Strategic HRM. This approach assumes a more or less static external system
In sharp contrast the configurational approach emphasizes fit with other systems within the organisation and fit with external characteristics.


Contrarian views

Contrarian practices are those practices that go counter to the conventional wisdom. For instance stockpile and train human resources in times of economic downturn, design jobs around the unique experiences, knowledge, skills, interests and abilities of current employees or newly hired employees.


Similarly in a related vein the question can be asked whether organisations can build in systems to provide time for development.
Thus the static best practices list needs to be extended to new and powerful ideas that open possibilities, stretch imagination and inspire change. Most useful ideas come from companies that faced a critical business problem and were forced to find a solution. The Message is that the Best practice is not the monopoly. Each one finds a unique way.
Supposing the Idea embraced by an innovative HR practice be : Client self sufficiency as the ultimate goal for Human Resource Management. The old Method would be when an employee needed to complete an HR transaction, the preferred sequence would be Person-Phone-desktop model where by force of habit the employee approaches the HR service provider first and the phone and self access are second and third priorities.


The new method would follow the sequence Desktop-Phone-Person model where the preferred method would be self help and only in case of necessity phone or approach the HR personnel for further service delivery . The Advantage is that the second model is less labour intensive than the first and is more technology oriented.


This model it can be seen demands newer behavioural orientations from the service deliverers as also the service receivers such as commitment on the use of information and communication technology. HR’s function therefore becomes more of orienting the workforce to the new behaviours using training and change initiatives and ultimately frees the HR staff for more creative, value adding jobs. An easy parallel example would be in the banking industry use of ATMs.


Some thoughts for the future coutesy Watson Wyatt Worldwide


HR can develop in newer directions in the following ways:



· Redefining the mission, role and structure of HR in the direction of making people a source of competitive advantage.



· Reducing the cost and increasing the value of HR support by asking outsourcing, automating and centralising questions.


· Identifying high impact people-management practices by stopping wasteful practices, prioritising practices to those having high impact.


· Re-engineering HR Processes in a way that enhances the creative use of people away from mere transactional roles.


· Using technology to streamline and automate administrative HR tasks by more interfaces with the IT department.


· Eliminating non essential, low value adding work. Often the truth is the HR dept. is adept at non critical areas.


· Building Management Accountability for implementing Effective People practices such as accountability for the training managers for end results rather than mere feel good responses to training, learning or behavioural change alone.

· Developing HR staff capabilities and skills such as more business savvy and consultative skills


· Redefining the Employment contract in an environment where employment security is out, continuous training is in and trainability being crucial from the recruitment stage itself.


· Quantifying the return on investment of HR initiatives. In which case the Linkage would be people– practices– business results under the general axiom that “If your employees are happy they will make the customers happy; happy customers in turn drives your competitive advantage.”


· Creating strong partnerships with line operations where HR must know the business to gain credibility with the line.


Thank you

Tuesday, June 1, 2010

"Mindset" and "culture"


Two words mindset and culture are similrly used and denotes the same. Here is an article trying to draw evidence from literature to highlight this point.



“Mindset” and “culture” : An instance of concept travelling. : Shelly Jose


In literature on research, especially relating to conceptualization of variables, the phenomena of concept travelling and concept stretching have been well discussed especially by Osigweh(1989). In a nutshell, concept travelling is desirable and stretching is not. Two different terms used with apparently the same meaning are ‘mindset’ and ‘culture’. Assuming the conceptualization of both is the same as will be explicated later however, the differentiation may serve a useful function.



According to Osigweh, “the extension of a concept refers to the class of things to which it applies, or the totality of objects which it identifies. The connotation of that same term refers to the sum total of characteristics or collection of properties that anything must possess to be denoted by the term.”



In the present instance, the argument is that the two terms ‘mindset’ and ‘culture’ are conceptualized in the same manner and refers to the same phenomena. The only reference to some difference is that the term mindset is used in a more social – psychological vein and culture in a more sociological vein. However, this apart, both terms refer to a collective phenomena throwing us back to the argument that both are conceptualized the same way, as the same theoretical phenomena denoted by ‘culture’, a type 3 concept.

Various Conceptualisations of the two terms


Culture is holistic, historically determined, related to things anthropologists study, socially constructed, soft and difficult to change. (p 179 Culture and Organisations, Hofstede). It has been variously described as the collective programming of the mind, software of the mind and a lens all of which distinguishes one group from another.
Both culture and mindset seems to be sharing the above characteristics especially the idea of social construction which is that actors interacting together form, over time, typifications or mental representations of each other's actions, eventually habitualized into reciprocal roles played by the actors in relation to each other and then routinized and institutionalized. In the process of this institutionalization, meaning is embedded and institutionalized into individuals and groups - knowledge and people's conception of (and therefore belief regarding) what reality 'is' becomes embedded into the institutional fabric and structure of the group. This process happens with groups of all levels such as organisations and is typified by the term ‘culture’.

Mindset denotes member’s understanding of the nature of reality that confronts them. Mindset is a collective awareness shared by the key internal stakeholders. (Kaiser, 1986). Mindset is the direction of one’s thinking (Mak, 1999). Mindsets denote patterns of sensemaking and behavior that capture the ways in which members frame situations, evaluate the alternatives and then select the responsible behaviours. (Liedtka, 1991)

Further Weick (1993) states that sense making is a process of committed interpretation akin to the organized nature of the perceptual field (Krech and Crutchfield, 1947). Mindset is a predisposition to see the world in a particular way that sets boundaries and provides explanations for why things are the way they are – a filter through which we look at the world. (Rhinesmith, 1992)

It is relevant to note that the idea of collective mind is present in the conceptualization of both culture and mindset. The idea of the common problems that all societies confront, as in the discussion on culture and the nature of reality that confronts people, as in the discussion on mindset are in essence the same. Some (Broekstra, 1996) even attribute that organizations have a mind and can be attributed with consciousness.


Levels of culture


‘Mindset’ – travelled culture
Taking from Osigweh’s idea of concept travelling and stretching, it appears that mindset is travelled culture, yielding flexibility, especially as in article on industry mindsets. (Phillips, 1994.) In the present case, since culture is too strong a word denoting and informing of a relatively close knit group or community, mindset denotes the same meaning which can be applied to similar groups albeit with lesser degree of face to face frequent interaction.



However, it is worth mentioning that when culture is spoken of as in national culture, assumptions of close face to face and frequent interactions of all the members has practical limitations. A notion of oneness and uniqueness however is assumed.



Further as Osigweh points out each meaning of a term under consideration used in varying contexts derives from the part that it plays in the theory. This is a characteristic of a type 3 concept.
In an article especially that of Phillips what has been done in the use of the term ‘mindset’ is extending the breadth of the concept of ‘culture’. The concept is general in the sense that it represents a large class. Therefore the concept of mindset is an extension of the concept of culture to a different setting. This is in line with the argument of Osigweh that the concept may be made extendable to a broader context (here industry) without however stretching the meaning which would be fallacious and distorting. Phillips mentions that in the article the two terms are used interchangeably.



The presence of a correlation between industry and organizational culture as in Chatman and Jehn, 1994, would invite recognition of an industry level culture. Culture influenced by industry characteristics at the level of industry would qualify as industry culture/mindset.
Further the presence of an industry level of culture is identified but not much studied or developed. Hofstede placed an industry culture between the occupational and the organizational levels as industry is characterized by distinct occupations and distinct organizations. (p 414, Culture’s Consequences). Gordon (1991) identifies the industry level of culture. And Spender (1989) identifies industry recipes.

‘Mindset’ and ‘mind-set’


A content analysis of Hofstede’s discussion on culture would throw insights into the use of the term ‘mindset’ as distinct from ‘mind-set’. The use of the word denoting that of an individual as distinct from a more collective one as in culture is denoted using a hyphen ‘mind-set, whereas the one denoting a collective idea is referred to as ‘mindset’.
In exploring his findings about different national cultures, Hofstede brings out several mental models of peoples such as machine, pyramid, family (to denote bureaucratic, hierarchic and clan respectively) as residing in their minds forming what in effect are mindsets paralleling Fisher (1988) using the term “mindset” and Douglas (1996) to refer to the “thought style”.



The rationale for the use of the term ‘mindset’ seems to be that culture is a strong word involving face to face interactions. In a gradation involving national, industry, occupational and organizational, industry has relatively less face to face interaction. At the industry level, the same or similar assumptions, environmental forces and broad technological categorizations do inform, infuse and influence the actors in the same industry albeit in different organisations.


Conclusion


In conclusion, there does not seem to be any difference between the terms culture and mindset as seen from its usage in the organizational theory literature. However mindset may serve a functional utility as when it may be used to denote culture in groups with lesser degree of face to face interactions




References


Articles and Books


Industry mindsets: Exploring the Cultures of Two Macro – Organisational Settings , Margaret E. Phillips, Organisation Sscience, Vol.5, No.3 (Aug., 1994), 384-402
Assessing the Relationship between Industry Characteristics and organistional Culture: How Different Can you be? Chatman and Jehn AMJ, vol 37. No. 3 Jun 1994 522- 553.
Concept fallibility in organizational science, Chimezie A. B. Osigweh, AMR, 1989, Vol 14 No. 4 579-594
Chapter 3 Mindsets and paradigms: The individual and the organization in times of change: Developing strategies for change John Darwin, Phil Johnson, John Mcauley, Pearson Education Ltd., 2002
An explanation of Industry, Culture and Revenue Growth, Edward W. Christensen, George G. Gordon, Organisation Studies 1999, 20/3 397-422

Content analysis


Rererences to ‘mindset’ and ‘mind-set’ in Culture’s Consequences, Hofstede, 1990

Drama in real office life

Sometime in 1998 when I was Senior Personnel Officer at a PSU in Bihar, the following dramatic conversation took place. I thought it would be worth blogging.

-------------------------------------------
The cast of the play is as follows
Jose sahab (31 years, south INDIAN ): Shelly Jose, SPAO
Ratan (54 years, Bihari on the verge of retirement proud of being the chief's peon for over 15 years): The peon to the CHRM
CHRM (50 years, proud and arrogant Punjabi) Chief Human Resources Manager

--------------------------------------------
The Situation is an Office in an Indian PSU of the late 1990s




CHRM: (Rings the bell and Ratan enters)
“Jose sahib ko bulao” ("Call Mr. Jose")


Ratan : (Comes to Jose sahab’s cabin. Points with a full stretched arm at Jose sahab and flexes his elbow backwards thumb pointing to CHRM’s cabin and says “ Jose sahab, bade sahab”. ( The curt short way is the peon’s way of indicating that the big boss is calling urgently and probably very serious matter even very threatening to the subordinate Mr. Shelly Jose.)


(Jose enters CHRM’s cabin)

CHRM: “Jose, what happened to the thrust area report”?

Jose : “It is getting prepared sir”.

CHRM: “Jaldi karo, GM ne kaha hai. GM kaha hai tho aur kuch karne ka nahin. Khali yehi karthe rahna hai”

"Make it fast, GM has told. If GM says dont do anything else jusy keep doing this"

(smiles as if he has some hidden meanings)

(Jose leaves and after two minutes enters with a floppy disk in his hands.)
CHRM: “Ho gaya”? ("Done?")

Jose : “Yes sir”


CHRM : “Kaham hai”? ("Where is it ?")


Jose: Floppy meim hai sahib. PC meim dikha detha hoom.("It is in the floppy , I will show in the PC")

CHRM: Floppy meim? ("In the floppy?") (Throws up both hands in surrender) “I don’t want any virus”.


Jose: Thiik hai sahib. Print nikaltha hoom.("Ok sir I will take a print out")

(After some time enters with a paper print out.)


CHRM ( Reads the paper. )“Is ka target ham log May 1998 diya tha?”
("We had given the target as May 1998?")


Jose : Ji sir, GM ne kaha tha.("Yes sir, GM had told")



CHRM: GM ne kaha tha? ("GM had told?")"Then I don’t want to change it” (Pauses, goes through the paper) "Yeh BPR iska ham log kyom commit karthe hai?" ("Why are we committing on this BPR?")

Jose: Sir, we have already sent the areas for BPR to HO.


CHRM: "Wo sab Bhalla level meim change kara doonga yaar".
("All that we will change at the level of Mr. Bhalla my dear friend" the CHRM at HO)


Jose: Thiik hai sir, ("ok sir")



CHRM: Pointing to the phone. "Gurcharan Singh ko lagao" ( "Call Gurucharan Singh, PA to CHRM At HO)


(Jose dials)

Jose: Sir, engaged aa raha hai.(" Getting an engaged tone")

CHRM: (Shaking his head) "I cant do anything about that."
(Pointing to the PC). "Dekho mera ek file gayab ho gaya hai , jara doondo." ("I had lost a file, just find")


Jose: (trying to start the PC) "Sir, password diijiye". ("Sir, Please give the password")

CHRM : "Thiik hai phir aap udhar dekho" ( "Then you look that side")


Jose: "Sir, screen me dikhega nahim" ( Sir, it will not be displayed on the screen")

CHRM: "Phir bhi aap udhar dekho" ( "Still you look that side")


--------------------------------------------