Where the mind is free........

Tuesday, June 1, 2010

Lone wolf explained

Perhaps it is time to explain the choice of the wolf meaning symbolically used, apart from the expression 'lone wolf'. The dictionary meaning of the expression is 'who prefers to go without the company or assistance of others'. True to the explanation below of the totem wolf, the lone wolf need not be unsocial or antisocial or asocial. It perhaps means more about the resistance to blind accultarisation characteristically explained also of self actualising people and also to situations that demand unconditional following. The lone wolf would rather be absent from such situations than be whiningly following the herd.











I am taking straight from the web site explaining the totem wolf:


To understand totem wolf symbols, one must first understand the heart of the Wolf. This takes time because the Wolf has had to endure many false stereotypes, misconceptions and misunderstandings.

Some common traits that accompany totem wolf symbols:

  • Intelligence
  • Cunning
  • Communication
  • Friendliness
  • Loyalty
  • Generosity
  • Compassion


Not at all the picture of ferocity or terror, the Wolf is a creature with a high sense of loyalty and strength. Another misconception is that of the “lone wolf.” To the contrary, the Wolf is actually a social creature, friendly, and gregarious with its counterparts.

The Wolf is an incredible communicator. By using touch, body movements, eye contact as well as many complex vocal expressions – the wolf makes his point understood. Those with totem wolf symbols are of the same inclination – they are expressive both vocally and physically. Those who have the wolf as their totem animal are naturally eloquent in speech, and also have knack for creative writing.


Totem wolf symbols belong to those who truly understand the depth of passion that belong to this noble creature. The Wolf is a representative of deep faith, and profound understanding.


Further, the Wolf possess a high intellect, and have been observed using strategies about hunting, habitat and migration.

In history, the totem Wolf symbol appears with the founders of Rome, Romulus and Remus. Legend has it that the two founding brothers were raised and suckled by a she-wolf.

In Norse mythology, the Wolf is a symbol for victory when ridden by Odin and the Valkyries upon the battlefield.

As a Celtic symbol, the Wolf was a source of lunar power. Celtic lore states that the Wolf would hunt down the sun and devour it at each dusk so as to allow the power of the moon to come forth.

In Asia, the wolf guards the doors that allow entrance to heavenly, celestial realms. The Wolf is also said to be among the ancestry of Genghis Khan.

When this gracious creature appears to us, and serves as a totem in our lives, the Wolf beckons us to ask these questions:

  • Are you thinking about a different form of education?
  • Are you being a true friend, and are your friends being true to you?
  • Are you communicating yourself clearly to others?
  • Are you being loyal to yourself?
  • Are you incorporating strategies and planning to achieve your goals?
  • Are you spending enough quality time with yourself, friends and family?

The frenzy of Money

It may well be my reaction or even overreaction to the events that this country witnessed since the liberalization of 1991. The people who were into their twenties during that year and onwards are considered to be the real beneficiaries of the LPG policies that India embarked on following a near fatal foreign exchange crunch. Do these people think differently? Do they approach life differently? I belong to an earlier generation who were born to parents of the inter world war years whose main motto was thrift, conservation and even suffering to save a paisa. In my quest or my tendency for a quest to identify and trace the roots of a particular behavior, I have found that the war had a tremendous influence on a generation which was on the verge of starvation and scarcity. The idea or the reality of scarcity was very real in the time of my parents’ childhood and even early adulthood. Food was what the local folk produced, clothing was what was available in the textile stores and buildings were of a certain kind and style of the times. There was definite limitations on the options available. My paternal ancestors’ dwelling was originally built as a place for keeping the implements of agriculture later on modified to be a dwelling place.


In comparison on my maternal side the dwelling was modern with porticoes and more than adequate ventilation a certain style of the times a remnant of the Portuguese style. Money was not really a necessity those days except for studies and may be travel both of which were sought only if necessary and possible. The monetization of economy was limited. There were no electricity bills, telephone bills and water bills since the first two were absent and the third was locally available. I remember the days with no electricity and only the wiring and switches and as children we used to play around with the switches with no penalties or scolding because the power was awaited. The evenings were lighted by kerosene lamps and anyone venturing out would make a torch of dry coconut leaves lighted and rhythmically heaved to provide the oxygen and breeze for the light to go on. I am an unlikely candidate for writing on these because soon the situation changed with the arrival of the electricity connection, torches powered by cells. It is only my extrapolation backwards that powers these comparative thoughts.
I can live in the yesteryear in my imagination. To such the LPG was a change in the environment and by the late 90s the generation that matured by then looked at a scenario totally changed although they never knew it. To them money was not a scarcity, products were not a in shortage and spending was not worth thinking. Perhaps making and investing predominated over spending which went without much thought.

Amidst this though, I do observe a kind of frenzy and a change of priority at various levels. While with the Indian Oil corporation I felt that the corporation was bewildered and did not know what to do with the changes. There was an ageing population that was mentally retired and there was a young group and in between were people like me although I might fit in very well with the latter except for my bend that gave birth to the kind of inner adventures that this blog is trying to capture. I saw the frenzy in Indian Oil Corporation , a kind of Indian Wotan if there is one and one of the topics of the training department was “Changes in ways of doing things”.

I saw it with Rajagiri College when they rapidly expanded into the newer educational opening up into engineering , MCA and so on and the kind of frenzy the powers were in.

But more importantly I saw the behavioural changes in people. I saw in it my roommate of IOC days, Mr. Dhinakaran and also in my wife. Dhinakaran moved on to BHEL and to Infosys, one a heavy engineering co and the other an IT company. He rapidly moved from Trichy to Chennai with his parents and got married to the daughter of a rich man. I saw the changes in his behavior. The scene had suddenly changed to making money and nothing else. Or everything else was secondary and out of the radar. And I saw it in my former wife too when she started earning like a windfall. The behavior and the tones of language changed more than the normal. That the circumstances can make such drastic changes in man was surprising to me. I am unable to say whether they are aware of it or whether they deliberately shed an old skin in favour of a new.


And I saw it in an unlikely candidate a friend of mine who had rootings in the language and literary side as well who however has mellowed and is aware of the uncertainties.


What does this bade for the kind of adventure that I am blogging on? First of all is an achievement independent of the circumstance? Or even the people who make the circumstance possible? Samuelson’s question in the elementary text book on economics as to whether the people would achieve howsoever their talents may be if they were transported to a desert? My great grandfather on the paternal side achieved well and amassed land in his time to leave for his three sons one of whom renounced and joined the priesthood. My grandfather could not boast of any such achievement.


My great great grandfather on the maternal side also achieved and built six houses with grain storage (arayum perayum in Malayalam). Down the line they did not. In fact such lineage became a burden as they could not shed the false pride and move on to the newer times that demanded flexibility and even meanness at times. My point is that personal achievements are not as personal in fact. One is fortunate to be at a certain economic clime without burdens of the past. I am not discounting the value of achievement , but one who can achieve well with this attitude that one’s achievements are the result not only of one’s own abilities, but due to standing on the shoulders of an economy that is the result of a previous generation’s struggle, is to me more of a MAN or a WOMAN.

Business Ethics Course


It was quite accidental that I was assigned the course on Business ethics. The year was 2002. I was tying up some loose ends in the family after tremendous dilemma as to the means. Since the ends were anyway better, there was no option as to the means.... the consequences otherwise would have been far more pathetic.


I was doing my readings on culture and Prof. James Thomas Kunnanat intuitively linked the same to ethics and suggested my name for handling the course. And here I was except for some reaidng skills.. and a book 'The story of Philosophy' by Will Durant adventuring on to the world of ethics.


The rest of it followed... and in late 2007 I posted a summary of the discussions for the benefit of the students.....


End of course module wise briefing

The syllabus of Business ethics and brief comments from me are as follows:-

Module 1.


Introduction to ethics as part of philosophy . Teleological and deontological theories. Justice, ethics, morality, ethics, and law.

Ethics is a branch of philosophy along with politics, logic, metaphysics, aesthetics. Politics in the philosophical meaning is the art of right social organization, Logic is the science of correct thinking, aesthetics is the science of beauty and harmony, metaphysics is the branch of philosophy that deals with higher order questions such as the existence of God and final meanings of life. Ethics deals with higher values especially rightness and wrongness of behaviour.

Teleological is the same as consequentialist which determines the ethics of an act on the basis of the consequences of the act.

Deontological theories on the other hand postulate that the act itself is either right or wrong irrespective of the consequences.

The most important deontological theory is the categorical imperative of Immanuel Kant. The other examples would be the golden rule , " Do to others as you would want them to do to you" and the ten commandments in the Judeo Christian tradition.

Also please recollect our discussion on various related terms such as morality, norms, law, culture and ethics. All of them have in common the question of right vs wrong.

Law has the backing of the legislature and is often written down. Norms are the practices followed in a community the breaking of which causes disdain. For example, greetings and participating in social events such as marriage, funeral etc would not be considered as crimes but would invite scorn and non cooperation from the community.

Morality usually has the backing of the religion and also may have some local and temporal standing as when we call the Victorian morals.

Culture also implies right vs wrong as when someone deviating from a culture is called a deviant and eccentric ( Away from the centre)

Ethics is usually of a particular domain such as business ethics and medical ethics.

We also talk about the protestant ethic a set of behaviors subscribed by the protestants which with its ideal of hard work, thrift, frugality and investment paved the way to the industrial revolution / capitalism.

Module 2

Business ethics - Ethical dilemmas - Ethical displacement- Ethical leadership - Ethical issues in leadership - Corruption- Discrimination- Whistle blowing- competition- Privacy - trade secrets

Business ethics deals with the questions of correctness of behavior in the domain of business. Ethical dilemmas include personal conflicts. Recollect the case of the defective bolts where Mr. Malhotra had to take a decision. Also recollect that we tried to find answers to the dilemma on the basis of the various moral philosophies such as utilitarianism ( "greatest good of the greatest number" , "cost- benefit analysis") , egoism ( behaviour on the basis of what is good for oneself) and enlightened egoism ( behavior on the basis of expectations of future benefits to oneself/ the company).

Also other philosophies include deontological such as categorical imperative ( it is inherently wrong not to disclose if there are defects in the product). One philosophy “relativism” may be particularly interesting to business ethics because it postulates to look at industry practices in similar circumstances.

Corruption was discussed around the corruption perception index prepared by Transparency international (TI) which does compile corruption data on the basis of a survey. Among the most corrupt is Nigeria. India is around the bottom 3 on a scale of 10. Least corrupt are the Scandinavian countries.

There may also be an inverse correlation between corruption and economic growth of a country. Arguments for the economic growth of least corrupt countries include the attraction of foreign investments to a less corrupt country. This is however on the assumption of the goodness of capital investment which is one of the tenets of capitalistic thinking.

There were also some arguments justifying corruption which however are morally unacceptable. These include that corruption smoothens the otherwise slow bureaucracy, that the salaries of bureaucrats are kept low in anticipation that anyway they will be bribed and most importantly that corruption is a cultural issue and not a moral one.


Discrimination in matters of employment and promotion was discussed from two angles. One in terms of conscious efforts from the nations to provide avenues to the historically deprived which in US is called affirmative action and in our own as reservation.

At the corporate and individual level discrimination may include conscious efforts to eliminate bias for which it may be a good idea to be aware of possible perceptual biases particularly halo effect, horn effect, recency effect , stereotyping etc.

Whistle blowing refers to employees raising and bringing out unacceptable practices by people and corporate. It earns significance from the point of view that often whistle blowers are at risk of losing jobs. Many countries have enacted laws protecting whistle blowers in the larger interests of the society


Competition is discussed at the larger level of capitalism itself as posing certain ethical issues. Capitalism is accused as a system that runs on the selfishness of the players and one that hinges on Spencer’s survival of the fittest. The unacceptability of applying an observation from natural world applied to higher order existence such as that of human beings with a civilization and culture is questioned. Besides taken to extreme survival of the fittest would mean leaving the sick and the aged to themselves and to their own peril. A system that runs on selfishness it is argued does not promote any higher ideals that distinguishes human existence.

Privacy is discussed at the level of corporate houses resorting to ethically unacceptable practices that monitors the behavior of employees especially using technology such as CCTV and telephone eavesdropping. At the consumer level this may mean infringement on personal time by say direct / telemarketers.


Trade secrets do pose two issues, one that of intellectual property being pilfered which is unacceptable ethically since a person or a corporate entity is rightfully entitled to enjoy the fruits of his intellectual labour. The second issue is that of life saving inventions being too closely held in the name of intellectual property. From both angles there are ethical issues.

Leadership issues of ethics are attached as ppt file.



Moduel 3.


Ethical issues in marketing, finance, HRM , IT and business strategy

Marketing and HRM ppts are attached. For finance please do a research on the Enron issue. I am doubtful whether anything more can be said about IT and strategy other that already said in the functional areas. Suffice it to say that the war metaphors used in strategy such as competition, overkill, market share, targeting etc. do influence business bahaviour in cut throat terms which in strict ethical terms does not promote any higher ideals.

Module 4.


Corporate governance, Social audit and government, CSR, Ethics in different nations.

Corporate governance ppt is attached. Others may please be referred in the light of the discussions. Briefly social audit would entail the impact of business upon society especially the negative ones. Ethics in different nations please see transparency international website and discussions on Corruption perception index.

Module 5.

Recent Corporate initiatives abroad and in India

Please refer to the Sarbanes Oxley Act and the SEBI guidelines

I am sure you will appreciate that we have covered much more than the syllabus and also the perspectives developed by the class sessions would let you read on further keeping in mind the university syllabus to fill gaps if any....


All the best

SHELLY JOSE

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Tragedies and ethics


The industrial tragedies are what they are. Well tragedies of industrial scale. They raise certain issues and fundamentally alter the conceptions of man's approach and relationship to nature and to the institutions that he has built. It takes no superior wisdom to understand that whatever man creates including institutions should be for the benefit of man, other living beings and of nature in general. In this vein it is worthwhile to examine the questions that the famous disasters or situations pose....

Exxon Valdez

The incident in its magnitude, raised for the first time the question of extending the definition of who is affected to the rest of the living beings as also to the non living environment in addition to people.

The present tendency is to consider the environment as well as the living and the human beings as integral part of the world and to consider any untoward damage or intrusion into the same as something compromising ethics.

A consequence of such thinking is the concern of more and more companies to think in terms of environmental protection and sustainable development. The importance of the case of Exxon Valdez is the new impetus to environmental awareness and mitigation efforts as above.


Johnson and Johnson Tylenol case

The case is an example of how to handle such crises positively. One would well like to think about the response of Cadbury’s in India a couple of years back when some batches of their product was found to be tainted with fungus. The first response of the company was to deny any responsibility and blame it on the distributors however at a very heavy cost. They then had to rope in a brand icon, Amitabh Bachhan to regain their market. The case points that more than mere good deeds, ethics does serve to enhance and preserve the value of reputation. In business terms we call reputation brand equity.

Also the incident brought about some creative innovation in the form of tamper proof packaging.


Ford Pinto case.

This case illustrates how an otherwise perfect decision using sound business tools such as cost benefit analysis can also be used in the wrong place. The use of cost benefit analysis in determining human value in dollar terms is questioned although what the company did was not incorrect legally. Also value of human lives needs sometimes to be calculated in dollar terms as in insurance / compensation etc.

The case also emphasizes the point about caveat vendor (let the seller beware) as it is difficult for lay consumers to make informed choices when it comes to complex products such as a car .

Challenger Disaster

In most organizations there is a predominance of one group over another. In the case of challenger/NASA/Morton Thiokol it was the management priorities prevailing over the technical correctness eventually leading to loss of lives and money and reputation.

The case also highlights the prevalence of group behavioral phenomena such as group think where the pressures of the group forces the individual to concede although all the pointers are in the opposite direction.

Also Asch effect which means that if you repeat a lie often enough it eventually may be perceived as the truth.

Similar was the case with Union Carbide (Bhopal Gas tragedy) where the workers were aware of the clear and present danger but their voice was not heard by the management due to the simple fact that they were workers. Actually the men on the ground know better sometimes than the management. Hierarchy does play a negative role there.

Shell Nigeria.

The case is important in as much as the company Shell tended to destroy a whole tribal land in which the people had not only economic and dwelling attachment but also the attachment over generations.

There is a strange collusion between the military, the government and the multinational company Shell against the very same people that a government is supposed to take care of. We call this collusion the military – government – industrial complex.

It may be that capitalism has reached a stage where the interests of the moneyed business and the interest of the politically powerful become the same and in the process the people suffer.

Also in a situation like the one faced by Shell, it remains a question whether a business has an option and /or a responsibility to leave or refuse to do business in a country which is corrupt and acts against its own people. Can not businesses do without such practices?

--------------


Tuesday, May 25, 2010

HUMAN RIGHTS AND CORPORATE LIFE





SHELLY JOSE
Lecturer, Rajagiri College of Social Sciences, Kalamaserry

PRESENTED AT
INTERDISCIPLINARY UGC REFRESHER PROGRAMME ON HUMAN RIGHTS FEB 3rd TO 23rd
ACADEMIC STAFF COLLEGE
UNIVERSITY OF CALICUT
JOHN MATTHAI CENTRE
TRICHUR






HUMAN RIGHTS AND CORPORATE LIFE


Introduction

In July 2005, the then UN Secretary General Kofi Annan appointed Professor John G. Ruggie to be Special Representative of the UN Secretary-General on business & human rights. A number of papers were invited and received by Prof. Ruggie’s office. Frequent themes included right to life liberty and security of person, forced labour, bonded labour, compulsory labour, child labour, right to privacy, freedom of association and collective bargaining, non-discrimination, workplace health and safety, right to an adequate standard of living and right to health.
Modern organisation is experienced by people as an additional locus of their existence; one that divides their lives into two distinct ones: the organisational and otherwise. Our era is characterized by the prevalence of mobility and extended times away imposed many a time by the demands of the organisation to which one belongs. A number of authors also express the same concern when discussing on work-life balance. Unfortunately no such topic is discussed under the human rights concerns.

Universal declaration of Human Rights

On 10th December 1948, the General Assembly of the United Nations adopted and proclaimed the Universal Declaration of Human Rights:

Article 16(3) states “the family is the natural and fundamental group unit of society and is entitled to protection by society and the State”.

Article 29(1) states “Everyone has duties to the community in which alone the free and full development of his personality is possible”.


This paper draws on the above and asks the question of what should organisations do to adequately address the issue of work life balance as a (human) right.




Two realities


Two realities of the present world are indisputable: the development and use of technology as a tool and the predominance of a formal organisation as economic vehicle. We have experiences with the first in its misuse leading to unspeakable misery not to mention human rights violations before during and after the world wars. We are experiencing currently a softer and slower but definite version of the ill effect of the latter as when increasingly the organisation eats into the lives of people leading to attrition of the primary social unit.

The organisation man (or woman)

In our day, the organisation man replaces the chivalrous knight of the middle ages and the gentleman of the Victorian times. The hero of our times is the organisation man. More and more of our lives are affected by organisations as when we are customers of a product produced by a business organisation. More importantly organisations are inevitable as a social system that provides the roles and positions and status through which participants deliver their work and services. In the process more and more of participants who otherwise wish to be on their own find themselves incapable of holding their own, a phenomena known as the ‘corporatisation of work’.

The choice therefore for the majority is to be either part of an organisation where one can contribute one’s labour or be left out economically and socially.

If we only consider the constitution of the US, we can see that the life envisaged is reduced to a right to living, liberty is reduced to the fatigued time left after devoting to the corporation and pursuit of happiness reduced to pursuit of money.

The reality of competition

John Kenneth Galbraith famously remarks in his book 'Affluent Society' about the transition of societies from deficiency paradigm of more and more demanded production to the surplus paradigm of marketing in which demands are fabricated to assist the off take of finished goods and to keep the economic machinery rolling. To produce more and to market more is the duty of the Corporate. And when the purchasing power of the consumer is low, there is a new consumer product called credit. In simple terms, irrespective of the ideology, the economic machinery dominates its creators than the other way around. This is an age old familiar theme celebarated in fictional warnings such as Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein.

The lament of collapse

In his paper, “The Twilight of American Culture” MORRIS BERMAN postulates that four factors are present when a civilization collapses:

Accelerating social and economic inequality,
Declining marginal returns with regard to investment in organisational solutions to socioeconomic problems
Rapidly dropping levels of literacy, critical understanding, and general intellectual awareness
Spiritual death or the emptying out of cultural content and the freezing or repackaging of it in formulas.

If we examine societies in particular and the world in general today we can see all the above ingredients in full measure.

We therefore see coexistence of improved economic conditions with increased anxiety about the erosion of economic and other values, increased socio economic problems such as suicide, divorce, family breakups and substance abuse, increased information avenues, with lack of wisdom and packaging of culture as saleable commodities. Capping it all is the bye product, environmental degradation.


The question of human rights

The former discussion was to put forth the thread of causes that bind us in the rat race that in turn leads to the degradation of our existence. Logically it should follow that to preserve human kind two areas need urgent attention: on the restoration of the fundamental unit of society namely family and to environmental restoration.


Both point towards a return to a less individualistic, less consumptive mode of existence. One such mode of alternate living is the eco-communalistic way.

What can organisations do or what should be done to organisations?

Organisations are the social machinery of the economy. If we accept that any human artifact is eventually for human well being rather than competition for its sake then it follows that the organisations must be given its rightful place below the other more fundamental social institutions such as the family and much below the more fundamental real nature. This would mean bringing a more sustainable production process that goes well with the cyclic nature of the natural environment and bringing in systems that makes society more inclusive.
Fortunately modern renewable technology answers the first and modern information technology can be the answer to the second. Wherever possible, organisations may allow flexitime and telecommuting as alternate ways of working rather than appropriating large amounts of time from its workforce. Telecommuting can reduce vehicular emissions considerably and provide increased time for human interaction as well.

Thus leveraging the gains of information technology one may postulate an e-communalism to supplement the eco – communalism mentioned earlier providing both environmental and social benefits.

Conclusion


In 1962, President John F. Kennedy outlined the Consumer Bill of Rights that codified the ethics of exchange between buyers and sellers. It is perhaps time to envisage a bill of rights to be named the employees’ bill of rights codifying the ethics of living agreed between the employers and employees. And in a strict sense, the employers as natural persons may be subsumed under the term employees and therefore the bill can be termed as bill of rights of “living in organisations”.

----------------

Type of Constructs and conflicts



Type of Constructs as taught by Prof. Pawar and conflicts as interpreted by Prof. Shelly Jose

The building blocks of all theories are concepts. Concepts are defined before they are used in a theory or a debate. Thoughts or the history of thought is full of concepts that are combined and recombined in theories after theories. The theories climb up the ladder of abstraction. Myths such as the myth of creation are also in a way explanations or theories which hold good for some time until replaced by better ones. For instance the biblical myth of creation would date the universe to around 7000 BC but science would not agree. The theory most widely accepted is the big bang theory.

Did the creation myth serve any purpose? It did and it does even today. The same scientist may be a Christian as well as a scientist. How can this be? Can the big bang theory and the creation myth co exist? It does sometimes in the same mind. For that matter, can the corpuscular theory and the wave theory of light co exist? It does. In fact many phenomena of light are explained by one of them rather than the other. So both are accepted and not discarded. In that case why shouldn’t the creation myth and the big bang co exist in the same mind?

Similarly there can be different theories of say Psychology such as Psychoanalytic, Behavioural, Gestalt, Transactional analysis all of them framing the same phenomena in different ways. It is therefore necessary to talk about constructs to understand the co existence of multiple theories to explain phenomena. Science and religion are not really antagonistic.

Type 1 constructs are those that we can see / perceive. For example the table. There is nothing inherently tablish about the combination of words that make up t-a-b-l-e. But over a period of time the Anglo Saxons have been using that particular combination of letters and sounds to mean a flat top on top of four at least three legs. In so far as a trapezium is drawn with four lines downward at appropriate angles and distances would give one the idea of a table or the concept of table. That is to say the mental schema of the type one constructs are fairly agreed upon by almost the entire civilised world.


Type 2 constructs are slightly more complex. They are not seen but can be seen using other devices. Bacteria or red blood corpuscles are examples. They are classified separately since they are not seen without some aid. So with radio waves which are explained in terms of the electromagnetic spectrum whose existence is scientifically established.



Type 3 constructs are slightly more difficult. They are created socially. Democracy is a good example. The particular democracy may vary across the world. But it has its beginnings in the sense of equalness that human beings came to idealise in the march of civilization. Without a sense of democracy there can be a vague sense of injustice, and rancour but no idea of say rights. And without rights there cannot be a sense of duty, both type 3 constructs themselves. As civilisation progressed things became more abstract. The sense of injustice was sort of sought to be resolved through the magna carta. And the ideas of equality, fraternity and liberty flew throughout Europe and the rest of the world. The Americans borrowed and adapted a great deal of it. One by one most of the world turned to democracy and is today implicitly assumed to be a universal value.
Can we see democracy? No. We can only see its indications. A protest, strike, ballot, elections and so on...

Type 4 constructs are even more removed from the world outside. They do have existence only in their own framework. For instance Psychoanalytic theory encompasses id, ego and super ego. They don’t mean anything or they do mean other things elsewhere or in isolation from the framework..

I think of all the four types of constructs the most difficult from a worldly and not academic point is the type three. Type one is fairly seen and agreed upon and is generally in the empirical domain. Type two and four are mostly engaged in by people specialized in certain domains. Type 3 is out there for everyone to interpret and misinterpret and squabble on. There is this one line in 'Black Hawk Down' a movie set in real life Somalian conflict. ‘We don’t want your democracy’. Similarly many other voices of dislike of the western style of democracy are not difficult to find.

Essay on Psychology


Accepting Psychology

I had started this as an essay on Jung but ended up as a brief on Psychology itself.

One of the early readings perhaps in 87-88 while I was pursuing my graduation in English Language and Literature at LOYOLA COLLEGE, Madras was a book titled “The Collective unconscious” of Carl Jung. I finished reading the book in a night which is rare for me. Several things stand out about the book. Apart from Freud who is sort of magazine stuff especially in serious Malayalam ones such as Mathrubhoomi, and popular psychology that is in the form of advice from columnists, this was my first exposure to the world of psychology.

The term as understood by the layman including me at an earlier time was that the psychologist is able to look into the eyes and say everything about your inner workings just like an astrologer or a palmist. This attaches a certain amount of mysticism around the Psychologist. Most magicians display better in this vein using what we understand as illusions. But when one really understands the magic it is nothing short of tricks.

The next exposure is when one studies Psychology as a paper. It talks about perception, learning, personality, attitudes, motivation, intelligence, emotions etc. in a kind of structural inevitability. That is to say because man is such and such and so he tends to do certain things in a certain way. For example man is capable of perceiving three dimensionally because he has two eyes that are spatially set apart optimally and in a straight forward frontal manner. Quite unlike the honey bee which has an aggregate eye, a sort of cluster of eyes that ‘sees’ the flower as not just as one but as a cluster of flowers. All the topics of Psychology mentioned above are in some way similarly discussed. The only dubious area for even the seasoned Psychologist is the Stimulus – Response theory of learning in its various types. The complexity of learning is discussed and the stimulus- response and the response – stimulus theories pooh-poohed by authors such as Arthur Koestler who in my opinion is less seriously considered than he deserves.

To my mind and to most Indian minds I believe western psychology of this sort leaves a sense of ‘there is something more’ that needs to be captured. The western obsession with analysis leaves much to be desired by the synthetic thinking of most of the orient. Very few of the western writes are gifted in the sort of synthesis that is essential to an understanding of worldly phenomena. This happens not within disciplines but across disciplines as well. But their analysis is beyond compare to be even.

Jung comes as a refreshing breeze amidst such. For once it does not start with the individual. Although Psychology deals with the individual, just as Sociology deals with the collective, it is very difficult or even impossible to think about the individual in isolation except in the terminal and cold stage. Anything that we speak about the individual in such a condition is merely the physically structural such as perception and its phenomena such as illusion and hallucination which are special cases of perception in its interaction with the external.

The individual is not as such but a product of the society. Be it the family or larger units of it. All psychology has to consider this contextual fact and attempts to separate the individual would lead to the kind of Psychology that Koestler calls ‘ratomorphic view of man’ or worse still ‘the anthropomorphic view of the rat’ that the stimulus – response theory states. This comes at two levels. The brain and the nervous system is progressively complex from rudimentary life to plants, animals and then higher apes and homo-sapiens. The other is the considerable interplay of social forces in its various gradations from the immediate motherly , to the siblings to the neighbour hood, to the village to the clan or the tribe to the occupational to the impersonal state or nation.
Even the rat that is studied in the laboratory is culled away from its collective to yield any completely valid display of ‘normal’ behaviour.

Jung in this context speaks about the collective not just the immediate living but also into the past through ages to the ancestral, unconscious that he postulates are in the mind of every one of the species. This leads to archetypes that have common symbolic values as well, as in the snake which evokes fear and is a symbol of evil and power of a certain kind.
He then proceeds to talk about the complexes, inferiority, superiority, Oedipus and Electra and traces the archetypes from myths and so forth. It is said that Freud only arranged what Shakespeare already knew and wrote in his plays. Jung to me arranged it far into the past in a grand plot. Does the collective behave in a manner as to expose and express the fears and anxieties of the individual? Is it possible to interpret world events in the light of Psychology? Jung does exactly the same. In his book on “Essays on contemporary events” he does interpret the German collective going back to the mythical Wotan the god of frenzy and restlessness which is so much part of the German Psyche expressed in the philosophy that rocked Europe towards the middle of the century. My curiosity extrapolates to Hofstede in his country metaphors for organizations. The metaphor for German organization is ‘the well oiled machine’. CAN we say the German psyche tends to mask its inner turmoil in external order and discipline in its perfect engineering? Will it some day break loose again?
The Russians put it in a different way that Psychology or the mental phenomena is a fine balance between excitation and restraint. Also quite acceptable to me in this rudimentary form. Jung calls the purpose of Psychology to be more and more of bringing to conscousness what is in the unconscious. Jiddu Krishnamurty always insisted on the pure awareness as against thought.

I have sort of traced the little Psychology that I know in tracing Jung. The other schools such as social learning of Bandura and the Gestalt Psychology and recently positive psychology and organizational Behaviour and the earlier humanism of Rogers and Maslow are I believe corrections to the deficiency Psychology which was a remnant of the post war years. I hope Psychology would develop in these directions more meaningfully. A further correction would be probably the dualistic thinking of white and black which seems to have created much of the hostility paradigms from individual conflicts to the blocs of the cold war. The black and white thinking needs to be replaced with shades of meanings and reality, more like a spectrum of reality where more and more of space is given to multiple realities in various levels of equilibrium.