Where the mind is free........

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

People who influenced me: Charles Dickens


I did a term paper in my undergraduate years on the theme 'Children in Dickens'. England comes personal rather than historical in Dickens. The book Oliver Twist is the one that was prescribed in our tenth standard. Great Expectations captured both the mind of the child and the aspirations of the times. There is also the surrealness of Miss Havisham who remained in her wedding dress in defiance of her love lost. The other novel David Copperfield has the character Mr. Micawber whose ideas of management of money is so profound as it is fundamental.

On the moral plane though most of his novels have a moral tone none simplifies it than 'A Christmas Carol'. The influence of Dickens is more in the kindling of interest in Literature and in hindsight a capturing of the times of which he wrote. The drawings in many of his novels captures in vivid detail the rustic English life.

Friday, August 21, 2009

People who influenced me: Miguel de Cervantez



Cervantez captured the medieval times perhaps almost as much as Walter Scott did. The greatness of Cervantez in 'The Adventures of don Quixote' is at once its many facetedness in the exposition so much so that it lends itself to many interpretations.

At times it is an expose of the folly of chivalry, an exultation of romantic values, the conflict between the rational and the visionary part of life in its portrayal of Don Quixote and Sancho Panza and above all its timelessness although set in medieval times.

In modern Management the organisation man is juxtaposed with the gentleman of the victorian era and the knight of the medieval times. No wonder don quixote is recommended reading in courses such as "Leadership: Competence, Vision and Mission" with immense insights to the student.

People who influenced me: Bertrand Russel



Russel's thinking is a lineage in a link that begins with the Age of Reason of Bacon and captures the pragmatic issues of the era. Although it is difficult to say which of the works has influenced me his 'Why I am not a Christian' had such a clarity about it so much so that Christ's greatness becomes even more clearer in his critique of Christianity. I believe it is the organised Christianity that he criticises rather than Christ the man. He was one among others who defined the essential characteristic of the twentieth century as one that exposed the nature of Man and one who warns of not using the rational part of Man in solving his problems.

People who influenced me: Samuel Beckett


Samuel Beckett's definitive place as one among the theatre of the absurds in capturing the essense of the 20th century is exemplified in the play 'Waiting for Godot' which has a lasting impression upon me. Waiting as the metaphor for life and the two characters Lucky and Pozzo as representing the humanity with its hierarchy of oppression by one on the other, captures the essense of a world which still does not lose an opportunity in chaining and subjugating the other.


In defiance of the conventions, Beckett answered to the question why there are only two chapters, 'because one would be too less and three would be too much' and to the question who is godot? he said ' if I knew I would have said it in the play' for me indicates the very sentiment of the man against any kind of oppression as the theme of the play.


People who influenced me; Arthur Koestler



Arthur Koestler wrote novels but more memorably non fiction. His 'Darkness at noon' is the most famous of his novels, but I would remember him for his non fiction trilogy ; The Sleepwalkers, The Act of Creation and The ghost in the machine. The fist one speaks about the non liniarity of scientific discoveries; such as that the heliocentric view of the world preceded the actual by about a century and a half and was left forgotten until Copernicus' theory was accepted lately.

The Act of creation intertwines evolution with human advancement and a whole lot of subjects in between. The ghost in the machine speaks about the delusional streak in the human mind where the hierarchical control of the new brain and the old brain are muddled leading to the psychotic streak in human history. He even considers it an evolutionary mistake to have a neo cortex that many times cannot override the limbic system which is the old brain. He also suggests that mankind should develop drugs to correct this mistake and administer them in the same way public water supply is dosed with iodine in certain iodine deficient countries.

Koestler himself was given to mental imbalances but I believe he has not been given his due among the intellectuals judging by the low citation elsewhere. I went all the way to Calcutta to purchase the three books.

People who influenced me: Amos Oz




Amos Oz is a Jewish writer. His 'A tale of Love and Darkness' influenced me immensely. I have not read any other of his novels but the simplicity and profoundness of his writing shakes me even now. Writing about the times post formation of Israel he vividly captures the idiosyncracies of the immigrant Jew mostly with European manners trying to come to terms with the lack of standards back in their own HOME country although it is their dream come true. His love of books goes with the fact of his father being a librarian. I admire him for being so capable of getting outside the Jewish self and examining his own people, but more importantly his complaints to his mother who committed suicide. The passage is so memorable of a child who has not reconciled to his mother leaving him forever... in such a way.

Defence pre submission

There was one more pre-submission defence at the SMS CUSAT yesterday. The presenter Siby Zacharia was as much confused about the topic as I was but I pretended I was listening. It occured to me initially that I was the only one not getting anything because all the others were apparently learned.

Then came the water up the boat. One by one there were questions and there were attempts by the others to quell saying we will ask the questions later and so on. It turned out that the very same doubts that I had was shared by the others as well.

For instance the question of what is consumer based brand equity as distinct from mere brand equity. The cluster based sampling technique was questioned. The quasi experimental design which it claimed was questioned and answered childishly. The use of terms like price, promotion etc were questioned.The classification of hedonistic, FMCG, utilitarian were not in marketing literature.

Then came the bombshell that one of them threw not at the presenter but at the guide that he being the doctoral committee member was not informed. Then how did he sign the presubmission form. He merely signed it.

Then another said there were instances where PhD was awarded without presubmission and none need claim sainthood etc. Also that inspite of these comments the scholar was still defending and not listening. That even after so much the scholar is not saying he would correct the mistakes.

The scholar tried to say politely that it was very difficult to get the questionnaires filled which was besides the technical points raised.

A saner one among them said there is some standard to which the university adheres and clearing it would tarnish if later on rejected.

The questions that remain for me are; Why did the guide not correct the scholar beforehand. What was the scholar doing all these years. Should not the faculty members show a united front at least during an auspicious occassion like this one so the observers get some respect for the university. Finally if post graduate teachers behave so what needs to be said of ordinary citizens. Has there been so much of erosion in our society's overworld. Then what would the underworld be?